SCANNER TECHSJASSI SINGH
← Blog

What Percentage of Solitaire Games Are Winnable?

About 89% of Klondike Solitaire deals can be won in Draw 1 and about 80% in Draw 3, but only by a player who could see every face-down card and never chose wrong. I ran 10,000 deals from my own Solitaire game through a solver for each mode to get those numbers. A simple player that can’t see the hidden cards won 50% of Draw 1 deals and 16% of Draw 3.

The numbers

The deals are my game’s numbered deals 1 to 10,000, under its rules: seven piles, only kings into an empty pile, the stock turned one or three at a time with unlimited passes, and cards allowed back down from the foundations.

Draw 1 Draw 3
Winnable (solver found a win) 88.7% 80.2%
Proven unwinnable 7.3% 14.8%
Undecided (search limit reached) 3.9% 5.0%
Won by a simple player 50.2% 15.7%
Deals 10,000 10,000

“Undecided” means the solver ran out of its search budget before it could either win the deal or prove nothing wins it. Some of those are winnable, so the true figures are a little higher than the first row: between 88.7% and 92.6% for Draw 1, and between 80.2% and 85.2% for Draw 3.

Why a solver wins so much more than you do

The solver knows where every card is, including the face-down ones. Researchers call this “thoughtful” Solitaire, and it is the only version anyone has been able to count exactly. It answers “can this deal be won at all?”, not “would a careful player win it?”.

When you play, the face-down cards are hidden. You often have two moves that look equally good, and only one leads to a win you can’t see yet. A deal can be winnable and still lost on the third move.

The simple player shows the gap. It presses the game’s Hint button and takes the first suggestion that doesn’t return to a position it has already been in. No lookahead and no undo. It won 50.2% of Draw 1 deals and 15.7% of Draw 3. For comparison, Solitaired, a large Solitaire site, says its players win 33% of Draw 1 games and 11.1% of Draw 3, without saying how many games that covers.

How it compares to the research

My figures agree with the best published ones. Charlie Blake and Ian Gent’s solver, Solvitaire, settled about a million Klondike deals and put Draw 1 at 90.48% and Draw 3 at 81.95% winnable (their paper, latest version 2024). Both sit inside my ranges above.

The figure you will also see quoted is 36.6%. That comes from a 2004 paper by Yan, Diaconis, Rusmevichientong and Van Roy, “Solitaire: Man Versus Machine”, in which an expert played and recorded 2,000 games of thoughtful Draw 3 and won 36.6% of them. That was with every card visible, so it is not a normal human win rate.

How I measured it

The solver is a depth-first search over every legal move, remembering positions it has already seen so it never explores one twice. If it runs out of positions without a win, the deal is proven unwinnable. It searched up to 4 million positions per deal. Two shortcuts from Blake and Gent’s paper keep it fast: any stock card you could reach by turning counts as one move, and a card goes straight to its foundation when nothing still in play could need it.

The deals come from the game’s own shuffling code, and every win the solver found was replayed through the game’s own move rules to check that it really ends with all 52 cards home. The 20,000 deals took about 23 minutes on a laptop. The simple player uses the game’s own Hint list and moves.

Play it

My Solitaire is free in the browser on a phone or a computer, with no download. It is standard Klondike as measured here: Draw 1 or Draw 3, unlimited passes, and cards can come back down from the foundations. It has a Hint button, three free undos per game, and a Finish button once every card is face up. Every deal has a number: add ?deal= and the number to the address to replay it.

Deals are random, not filtered, so about 1 Draw 1 deal in 10 and 1 Draw 3 deal in 5 can’t be won. If you’re going round in circles, Give up ends the deal.

Questions people ask

Are all Solitaire games winnable?

No. In Klondike, the Solitaire most people mean, about 1 deal in 10 can't be won in Draw 1 and about 1 in 5 in Draw 3, even by a player who could see every face-down card and never made a mistake.

What is a good Solitaire win rate?

A player that simply took the first sensible move every time won 50% of Draw 1 deals and 16% of Draw 3 in my tests. Winning more than that over a few hundred games means you are planning ahead.

Is Draw 3 Solitaire harder than Draw 1?

Yes. You can only play every third stock card on each pass, so a card you need can stay buried. In my tests 14.8% of Draw 3 deals were provably unwinnable against 7.3% of Draw 1, and a simple player won 16% instead of 50%.

The game

SolitaireBrowserBuild the four suits from ace to king. Draw one or three, tap or drag, with hints.